Testing new marketing channels without a process is how budgets get wasted. You run something for a few weeks, it doesn’t work immediately, you pull out and conclude “that channel doesn’t work for us” - when the real problem was that you never gave it fair conditions in the first place. Below is the process I use to evaluate channels in a structured way.
-
Define Your Goals and Audience: Before anything else, get clear on what you’re trying to achieve (sales, leads, brand awareness) and who you’re trying to reach. This determines which channels are even worth considering and what you’ll be measuring.
-
Identify Potential Marketing Channels: Map out the channels available: paid social, search, SEO, email, affiliate, influencer, display, and anything else that could plausibly reach your audience. Don’t start by eliminating - start by listing, then narrow.
-
Prioritize Channels: Not all channels will be equally relevant for your business. Prioritize based on where your audience actually spends time, what your competitors are doing, and what resources you can realistically commit. A multi-channel presence is often better than a single-channel bet, but you can’t test everything at once.
-
Set Measurable KPIs: Establish specific KPIs before you launch: website traffic, conversion rate, CTR, CPA, ROI. Ensure they connect directly to the goals you set in step one. If you don’t define what success looks like in advance, you’ll spend the analysis phase rationalizing instead of learning.
-
Allocate Resources: Assign budget, time, and team capacity to each channel based on your priority ranking. Some channels need ongoing maintenance to perform; others like SEO need a ramp-up period before results show. Factor that into how you set expectations and how long you commit to running the test.
-
Create Distinct Campaigns: Build campaigns tailored to each channel’s format and audience behavior. The copy, creative, and offer that works on paid search won’t necessarily translate to paid social or email. Consistency in brand and message is necessary; identical creative is not.
-
Launch and Monitor: Execute the campaigns and track performance against the KPIs you set. Use Google Analytics, platform-native dashboards, or whatever centralized reporting setup you have. The goal at this stage is observation, not intervention - let the data accumulate before you start adjusting.
-
A/B Testing Within Channels: Once each channel is running, test variables within it: ad copy, visuals, landing pages, targeting. This is separate from the channel-level test - you’re not asking “does this channel work,” you’re asking “what makes this channel work best.” See my guide to A/B testing paid ads for more on this.
-
Gather Feedback: Customer feedback through surveys, reviews, and direct comments can surface things the quantitative data misses (particularly around messaging clarity and friction points). This is most useful for channels that involve direct customer touchpoints.
-
Analyze Results and Adjust: Once you have enough data, assess each channel against your KPIs. Which channels are performing? Which aren’t? Put more resources into what’s working and either adjust or cut what isn’t. “Adjust” means making specific changes; it doesn’t mean lowering your KPIs.
-
Iterate and Scale: Channel testing is ongoing, not a one-time exercise. As you gather more data, expand on what’s working and continue exploring new channels as your business evolves. What didn’t work six months ago might work now if conditions have changed.
The process itself isn’t complicated. The discipline required to follow it (setting KPIs before you look at results, giving tests enough runway, being willing to cut channels that don’t perform) is harder than it sounds.